| Year | Name- High School- Sport | College |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 | Alex DeCarlo- WK- Swim | Findlay University |
| 2024 | Dexter Jones- WK- Swim | Gannon University |
| 2023 | Paige Delma- WK- Swim | The Ohio State University |
| Nathan Ambler- WK- Swim | DePauw University | |
| Christopher Rincher- WK- Swim | Case Western Reserve University | |
| Sloane Antonetz- TW- Swim | University of Nothern Colorado | |
| Charlotte Helm- TW- Swim | The College of Wooster | |
| Zach Barnes- TW- Swim | Cleveland State University | |
| Alex Cooper- TW- Swim | Baldwin Wallace University | |
| Matt Fralic- TW- Swim | Xavier University | |
| Connor Florence- TW- Swim | American University | |
| 2022 | Evie DeCarlo- WK - Swim | Northern Michigan University |
| 2021 | Lauren Richner - WK - Swim | Denison |
| 2018 | Qunetin Bartram- WK- Swim | Monmouth |
| Becca Taylor- TW- Swim | Denison | |
| 2017 | Gabe Finch- TW- Swim | Iona |
| Logan Indest- WK- Swim | Allegheny | |
| 2016 | Elissa Machester- WK- Swim | Wittenberg |
| 2015 | Kaylee Witkiewicz- TW- Swim | The Ohio State University |
| 2013 | Maren Reeder- TW- Swim | The Ohio State University |
| Trenton Harper- TW- Swim | Buffalo/Cinncinati | |
| Abby Jank- TW- Swim | Grove City | |
| 2012 | Keeler Callahan- WK- Swim | The Ohio State University |
| Hunter Atha- WK- Dive | Wisconson/ Arizona State University | |
| 2011 | Claudia Doyle- TW- Swim | Buffalo |
| Carly Davis- TW- Swim | Xavier | |
| Sam Reeder- TW- Swim | Miami (OH) | |
| Phil Mueller- TW- Swim | Wheeling Jesuit | |
| Katie Reiter- WK- Swim | Messiah University | |
| 2010 | Margret Rechel- TW- Swim | Calvin University |
| 2009 | Justin Andradi- TW- Swim | Ohio Nothern University |
| 2006 | Eric Ness- TW- Swim | Duke |
| Hilary Campbell- WK- Swim | Emory | |
| Megan Alexander- WK- Swim | The Ohio State University | |
| 2005 | Kendal Callahan- WK- Swim | The Ohio State University |
| 2004 | Annie Rennabohm- TW- Swim | The Ohio State University |
| Jason Rechel- TW- Swim | Bucknell | |
| Madeline Merrill- WK- Swim | New York University | |
| 2002 | Michael Joyce- WK- Swim | Ohio University |
| Katie Ness- TW- Swim | Duke | |
| Heather Rennabohm- TW- Swim | Ohio University | |
| Greg Bowne- WK- Swim | St. Louis | |
| 2001 | Emily Moore- WK- Swim | Indiana |
| Jill Collins- WK- Swim | Purdue | |
| 1999 | Troy Blanton- TW- Swim | Wisconsin |
| Erin Stanley- TW- Swim | Denison | |
| Chris Cook- WK- Swim | Case Western | |
| 1997 | Adam Minister- TW- Swim | William & Mary |
| Elizabeth Bradley- WK- Swim | Wittenberg | |
| Johnathon Bradley- WK- Swim | Wittenberg | |
| Paul Blanton- TW- Swim | West Point | |
| Abby Stewart- WK- Swim | Denison | |
| Tracy MaCauley- WK- Swim | South Carolina | |
| 1996 | Ryan Allinder- WK- Swim | The Ohio State University |
| Leah Favret- TW- Swim | Denver | |
| Todd MaCauley- WK- Swim | Denison | |
| Kevin Butler- TW- Swim | Arizona State University | |
| Rory McVay- TW- Swim | Arizona State University | |
| Ben Minister- TW- Swim | Richmond | |
| 1995 | Geoff Gear- WK- Swim | Univeristy of Massachusetts |
| 1994 | Mandi Allinder- WK- Swim | Eastern Michigan |
| Karen Buchmueller- WK- Swim | Wooster | |
| Jeremy Ahijevych- TW- Swim | Ohio Northern University | |
| 1993 | Ryan McKinley- TW- Swim | Ohio University |
| Tammy Helter- TW- Swim | Ohio University | |
| Dan Posthwaite- TW- Dive | Ohio University | |
| 1991 | Sean McKinley- Wor- Swim | Ohio University |
| Jon Warnick- Wor- Swim | Bowling Green | |
| James Zwyer- Wor- Swim | Air Force Academy | |
| Justin Sochor- Wor- Dive | Cleveland State University | |
| 1990 | Sonja Leiter- Wor- Swim | Georgia |
| Caroline Peticolas- Wor- Swim | Kenyon | |
| 1989 | Chris Harsh- Wor- Swim | Ohio University |
| Sheri White- Wor- Swim | University of Southern California | |
| Mandie Dieter- Wor- Swim | Wright State | |
| 1988 | Rick Yurich- Wor- Swim | Michigan State |
| Allison Peticolas- Wor- Swim | Principia | |
| 1987 | Kathy Littig- Wor- Swim | N.C. State |
| Jenny Jones- Wor- Swim | Maryland | |
| 1986 | Chris Dieter- Wor- Swim | Wright State |
| Craig Faircloth- Wor- Swim | Eastern Carolina University | |
| Brian Peticolas- Wor- Swim | Principia | |
| 1985 | Dave Greenlee- Wor- Swim | Kenyon |
| Mark Lang- Wor- Swim | Maryland | |
| Laurie Huff- Swim | The Ohio State University | |
| Mike Wallace- Swim | Bowling Green | |
| 1984 | Ned Skinner- Wor- Swim | Lousiana State University |
| James Allen - Wor- Swim | The Ohio State University | |
| Dan Erseley- Wor- Swim | Bowling Green | |
| Karen Taylor- Wor- Swim | Alabama | |
| Kelly Davis- Wor- Swim | Miami (OH) | |
| Jim Fisher- Wor- Dive | Indiana | |
| 1983 | Tim Jurs- Wor- Swim | Wright State |
| Matt Topper- Wor- Swim | The Ohio State University | |
| Craig Hummer- Wor- Swim | Kenyon | |
| Karen Olilla- Wor- Swim | Illinois | |
| 1982 | Dan McFarland- Wor- Swim | Bowling Green |
